Thursday, 13 February 2020

From GregB: For A September Day Near Quebec In 1759 (107Points)

The 28th Foot - 28mm figures from Warlord Games.
So...this is a bit...different. Apologies in advance for what might a longer post...you see, this is a sort of secret project, one I had hoped to work on, under wraps, until I could just sort of surprise everyone one day with a game...but this is a plan that was just not going to work. So here we are. 

The 35th foot, ready to give a volley. 28mm figures from Front Rank.
I guess we can just start with the technical bits - here are the British 28th and and 35th Regiments of Foot. These are 28mm castings.  The 28th Regiment (with the yellow facings)  are metal figures from Warlord Games. The 35th Regiment (with orange facings) are metal figures from Front Rank - although both casualty figures are also Front Rank castings. All flags are from GMB. These figures are intended to provide tabletop representation of British infantry units which served in the Seven Years War. In one specific battle...

The Siege of Quebec 

An engraving showing Wolfe's army making their daring crossing of the St. Lawrence and assaulting Quebec.
I was born and raised in the Canadian prairies, in the City of Winnipeg. My hometown is, give or take, about 2,500 kilometres from the beautiful City of Quebec, in the Canadian province of the same name. This distance physically, geographically and culturally between Winnipeg and Quebec City is significant. Yet a great deal about the life I have been fortunate to lead to this point here in Canada was shaped by the events which occurred outside Quebec City on September 13, 1759, during the Seven Years War. On this day a European-style field engagement took place between a British force led by British General James Wolfe and the French forces of General Louis-Joseph Montcalm.  This was the battle of the Plains of Abraham.

Officer on the left, keeping thing in order...
As battles of the era go, this one was small, and relatively short - a shattering volley of musketry from the British side settling matters and sending the French reeling. This was not Leuthen or Zorndorf or Minden. But its impact on history was significant, leading to the fall of "New France" and, for a time, British rule over a substantial portion of North America - until certain subsequent events...the Battle of the Plains of Abraham is an important moment in the history of the country known today as "Canada".

The uniforms of the British infantry musicians in that era were really something...
The British conquered "New France", and in subsequent negotiations, ended up keeping the territory (a story best relayed in another post by someone qualified to tell it, and not me).  Canada today is a largely peaceful positive place to be. We generally coexist and get along.  It's not perfect - nothing is I suppose, but it's perfect for me. I'm blessed to call it home, and so many in the world would give anything to have our "problems".

Rear view showing the detail on the Front Rank sculpts. Very nice, very pleasing to paint!
That said, old disputes can...linger? I don't want to burden Challengers with politics, but for now let's just say that in Canada the cultural differences between French and English maybe haven't 100% completely and totally gone away even after all of this time. And, it must be noted, this view leaves out the perspective of Indigenous Canadians - also not something I'm any position to offer wisdom on. Let's just say...a ways to go there too.

Rear detail on the Warlord sculpts - the grenadiers are fully loaded, but the regular troops are not carrying as much.
The lines of history are amazing to me...so much drawing back to this one battle, a brief and yet so significant engagement, a turning point in history.  So, so much, even today, all going back to that one moment.

I studied it all from when I was very young.  I visited Quebec City in junior high, and was stunned by the battlefield park, the walls of Old Quebec, the old cannons...wow, it captured my imagination. Our teachers in school had their biases, and in their telling this battle was just one more hapless military moment for France - just like WW2 (France as a hopeless case in things military is a staple of popular culture and history in North America). But of course nothing is so simple. I read the amazing book "Death or Victory" by Dan Snow.  It is an amazing read, and it is fascinating to put the battle that day into its proper context of a drawn out and dangerous summer campaign - one that was actually quite terrifying and vicious. Yes, the British won, but it was a close-run thing.  There is so much more to share - for example,  strangely, my high school history left out the part where the French returned to Quebec the next year and defeated the British at the Battle of St. Foy... :)

But I'm already blabbing too long about this. That is all best left for other posts or comments from smarter people.

A little closer view of the command and colour party - that one ensign is carrying, like, a broadsword? In one hand? Bad @ss fellow, I'm sure. Odd sculpt. But overall, I really enjoy these Warlord figures.
Some years ago, it occurred to me that it might be fun to wargame this battle.  I know many gamers do the "French & Indian War", but I was very focused on this one battle: Plains of Abraham, that battle, that moment - that was what I was interested in, not a skirmish in the woods.  This one, formed up, European-style battle that took place in North America in the Seven Years War.  Cool uniforms, history...man, it would be so neat!

Read this book!!
I started doing the research, faffing around with figures, which scale etc. This consumed, like, years - I mean, I was always painting something else too, so hardly hobby paralysis - but this project was going in my mind for a long, long time...I don't know why, but I thought I could, somehow, paint all of the units and surprise everyone. But, like, come on...that was dumb.

Besides, I can't earn points with secret projects, right? So as I finished the final grenadiers with yellow facings, I thought I would share what I have so far with my fellow Challengers. Some of these figures were painted outside of the Challenge period, but I was so excited with how they look all together, I just wanted to show them all. 

The 35th and 28th Foot were on the right of Wolfe's battle line that day in 1759.  The 35th seemed unique because they had orange facings, and even now when I see them I feel like having some ice cream for some reason.
Many thanks to Byron and his 3D printer for making the little dice trays that I placed on to the casualty markers.
The Front Rank figures are a lot of fun. I love the sculpts. The heft. They are just great and relaxing to paint.  But Front Rank sadly charge extortionate amounts for shipping and their "battalion packs" are a bit...unusual, at least for me (YMMV).  The main bump for me is the inclusion of two musicians in the 24-figure pack.  Again, it's all personal taste, but that is not what I would do with a 24-figure unit. Also...the uniforms of the British musicians are insane - certainly a challenge to paint, and doing two of them per unit isn't my ideal...although it's a chance to practice, I guess!

A casualty figure on a round base - with a little tray for dice useful to mark casualties for different game systems.
The Warlord sculpts are very, very nice.  Huge bonus - the Warlord musicians and grenadiers have the details on their hats and uniforms cast right into the figures...it's pretty amazing! Great stuff.  But Warlord sometimes is just...odd. In this case, the unit boxes come with 18 figures.  This is a strange number, when so many people out there use 12 or 24 figures for a unit.  You can buy extra musketeers of course, but it's very strange/irritating.  Seems like a GW-style move to me.

Gotta love the grenadiers! Man...those hats...great sculpts from Warlord.
I'm working my way "along the line" on this project.  I have it relatively mapped out...will still take a while, I'm sure, though hopefully the Challenge and just general posting and sharing pictures will help it go faster.  I might change up my approach - the so-called "Louisbourg Grenadiers" would be up next for the British line, so I might change gears and start on the left of Montcalm's opposing line, or just skip to the British centre.  There are still things to figure out in terms of representing the Louisbourg Grenadiers on the table - would they have carried a standard? If so, which regiment, the senior one? Would their officers have mitres or tricornes? Things to ponder.

The line starts to take shape on the Plains of My Kitchen Island.
Anyway, my brushes have turned to things Byzantine for now. But I hope to have more to share with this project as I go along - if not during this edition of the Painting Challenge, then at a later time. Thanks for reading, and I hope you are not asleep.

For scoring, there are 20 complete 28mm figures, and one prone 28mm figure (one of the casualty figures) out of this whole lot that were painted during the Challenge, so I think that works out to 102.5 points? Cheers everyone!

Really interesting, I have a 1950's book on the Battle, must get it read. The units are lovely and a nice period to recreate. A flag bonus to take you to 107

Martin

29 comments:

  1. Fantastic British foot from a classic period that I still remember reading about in my British Empire bound magazines as a kid. Lovely finish on these characterful sculpts and of course interesting additional fact Captain Cook helped navigate up the river so the Brits could clamber up the heights!
    Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Iain! Yes - the river was a particular challenge, and the support of the Royal Navy certainly was essential for success in 1759.

      Delete
  2. Fabulous!! I love these secret reveals. Beautiful work dude - just stunning. I know we've been chatting about doing The Plains of Abraham for years (with me even acquiring a boatload of Minden Miniatures both sides a while back), so I'm over the moon to see this one getting launched. Looking forward to more and, with your impetus, adding a few units to the mix. Bravo!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks very much dude, much appreciated!

      Delete
    2. Hey Curt if those Minden figures are deep in your lead pile 8 could find a home for them....

      Delete
    3. Nope, sawee. I'm going to hang onto them just to torment you. Maybe I'll paint them as a 40K imperial guard regiment... ;)

      Delete
  3. Awesome project Greg! Your British look of course fabulous and I can very well understand your fascination for that one battle. When I was in Quebec in my late teens I found it a rather strange place. Beautiful to look at but rather disconcerting that in all other places in Canada texts on memorials or in museums were in both English and French. Not so in the francophone part of your wonderful country. At that time, with typical youthful arrogance, I put that down to typical 'french' behaviour without realizing the deeper causes for that cultural divide.
    But as a Bavarian I can somehow understand that wish for independence. In an ideal world I'd rather live in an autonomous Bavaria as opposed to a Bavaria ruled from Berlin. But all things considered the status Quo probably ain't so bad after all and I'm slowly getting old and grumpy ;-)
    Back to the figures! As stated above they're just lovely and I hope to see more of this wonderful project soon.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Nick! My mom's family is 1/2 francophone, so I have felt the cultural divides of Canada for sure. It was French Immersion for me :)

      Delete
  4. Stunning unit - beautifully painted. Must also congratulate you on the teapot. Every home should have one.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No surprise our teapot photobombed in this post - considering the colours of the units after all :)

      Thanks!

      Delete
  5. Ooh two massive thumbs up 👍 here Greg! Lovely figures and a lovely period. I’m always amused by others take on units and manufacturers. I find the Front Rank Battalion packs most cost efficient, use 24 man units and love painting musicians! Are the Warlord FIW figures better than their AWi plastics? I tried some of their Hessians and gave up in disgust.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Peter. Front Rank's individual figure cost is no big deal, but it is their shipping - a percentage of the order, no matter the size. It's ridiculous.

      I have not tried Warlord plastics from the AWI period, so I can't help you there, but I find in general it is good to be wary of Warlord plastics. But their FWI metal figures are amazing!

      Delete
    2. I only order 24 figs at a time, and with the VAt removed it’s very good pricing.

      Delete
  6. Very, very nice looking regiments Greg! Very interesting background read to include some personal history. The period is also great one to delve into.

    Christopher

    ReplyDelete
  7. Fascinating post and truly excellent painting. Looking forward to more!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the comment, much appreciated.

      Delete
  8. Nice history and great paint work!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Superb painting Greg. I have a very soft spot for the 35th, as I was the Curator of the Royal Sussex Regimental Museum for many years. They were raised in 1701 by the Earl of Donegall at his own expense for William of Orange, and as a mark of gratitude, King Billy gave them the unique distinction of orange facings. Tradition has it that they drove of the Regiment Royal Roussillon during the battle, picked up their plumes, and placed them in their own hats - hence the later nickname, the "Orange Lilies." You have inspired me, and if I make the cut for the next Challenge, you may well see some more orange.

    Cheers,
    Richard

    ReplyDelete
  10. Splendid troops, Greg, but I fear that your campaign of secrecy is over!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Evan! Yeah, not sure how I was going to finish the whole thing without sharing...this approach is more fun anyways :)

      Delete
  11. There's nothing that beats the look of a well done Thin Red Line, simply gorgeous! King George commands and we obey, over the hills...

    ReplyDelete
  12. Great work Greg! Completely agree with the since today boased view of this war as a monumental French fuck-up, which it definitely was not.

    So...when are you painting the good guys, i.e. the pure, noble-hearted french canadians?

    ReplyDelete
  13. History wise, Staceys book is very good and shows how much of a desperate last roll of the dice the final attack was. Also shows how much of the victory was down to the Navy’s help.

    ReplyDelete